SocraticGadfly

December 07, 2021

Coronavirus week 87: It marches on — from Huanan Market? And into wingnut stupidity

That's the theme of David Dayen's piece at Prospect. "It marches on." COVID, if you personalize it, doesn't care that many people are tired of lockdowns. It marches on. He notes that more than the Black Lives Matter protests, in some ways, the anti-restrictions protests (sorry, but they weren't "lockdowns, and framing itself is an issue)

==

Now, the main piece:

A new piece at Science claims that we can determine pretty well that Huanan Market was the epicenter of the outbreak. Couple of notes on that. First, even if so, that doesn't mean that WIV's lax protocols still didn't have an indirect hand in this, including experimentation inside the lab leading to a leak which infected wet-market animals. Second, and speaking of, this is a raccoon dog. Per photo at left, yes, it does look kind of like a raccoon, but per the second half of the name, it's a canid most closely related to foxes. And, per the likes of Alina Chan in her new book, if so, it still doesn't make Xi Jinping Thought any more trustworthy on this issue.

Per Tablet Mag, there's additional reason to say this piee does NOT close the door on WIV. It notes that Richard Ebright Tweeted that workers at Chinese labs were known to sell test animals to wet markets.  In this case, no, not a lab leak, but still, HUGE lab sloppiness.

Michael Worobey, the author of the Science piece, says he considered a lab leak in the past, openly. That said, his wet market statement is by-him admittedly based on Chinese research. Alina Chan, who's written a book about everything problematic with China on the issue, and being Chinese-American, undercuts the racism angle, says Worobey has only one piece of the puzzle.

I agree.

==

Now, the rest of the roundup.

Dayan also talks about the Great Resignation in a longer piece; he analogizes COVID to the first big hit of the plague in Europe in the 1300s and how the dramatic cuts in workforce due to plague deaths liberated and empowered the still living.

Balloon Juice has a good roundup of omicron news and stupidity along with general COVID news, stupidity and conspiracy theory reports. One interesting fact is that many early omicron cases reported in Botswana were from European diplomats traveling there. Full story here. Friendly reminder that Angela Merkel is more of a capitalist, bad side, than Status Quo Joe. Also from that roundup? Whenever wingnuts claim that they support the science on this issue, remind them that Missouri's governor blocked the release to the public of a study by his own state's Department of Health and Senior Services that showed mask mandates work. And in international wingnut news, Brazil's Supreme Court has officially OKed a probe into President Jair Bolsinaro's repeated claim that vaccines cause AIDS.

Zeynep Tufekci has an open-thread type update, extracted from Tweets. The main thing she's right on is that it's too soon to tell about severity. She also reminds that antibodies are only one part of the immune system, something some in the science community kind of overlooked last week when attacking BioNTech's cofounder for saying their Pfizer and other vaccines will likely still offer a decent amount of protection. Go read the whole thing, though. Several thoughts there.

Omicron cases look to grow rapidly in the UK.

Reinfection appears fairly high in the previously infected; and so far, as with Delta, infection severity is worse in those with infectious immunity than with the vaccinated, per Katelyn Jetalina.

COVID antivaxxerism and the claim that we just need better nutrition or some "supplements" tain't so new after all. Learn about America's big polio antivaxxer.

December 06, 2021

Cooperstown veterans committees are fuck-ups again

Buck O'Neil? Hellz, yes. But none of the others they voted in deserve there.

Oh fuck, for fuck's sake.

(And, and to deliberately redouble on something? Contra one commenter, it is NOT the fucking official job description of various incarnations of the veterans committees to "elect" more people. It IS their job to "reconsider" people not elected by the BBWAA.

Now, the capitalists running the HOF will deny that's the unofficial job description; they're deny that's why they tweaked the three committees into four. But, they're lying out their smokestacks.

The whole reason the HOF exists is built on a legend, and the HOF and Cooperstown's wallets are heavily invested in that. I have a late friend who was born and raised there; I know whereof I speak on this sidebar. IMO, overall, hoops and football have better processes.) 

This guy GETS IT:

At the end of the day, it is a plaque in the gallery…and lots of merchandise sold for MLB teams, and the Hall of Fame. It also allows the newly elected Hall of Famer to charge extra for appearances and autographs.

Nothing to add.

Minnie Miñoso ain't a HOFer, and Gil Hodges ain't even a AAA HOFer. Jim Kaat and Tony Oliva don't belong in either.  

(Update, Dec. 22: I now have more detailed looks at the cases against, especially, Oliva and Hodges, and also against Miñoso.)

Same shitheads who voted in Jack Morris and Harold Baines proved they're even more stupid than the Bill Terry and Frankie Frisch veterans committee, notorious for putting in undeserving people like Jim Bottomley. (For that matter, there's a damn good argument writers fucked up voting in Terry, with less than 60 WAR, basically just because .400.)

Seriously, as batters, did committee members Ozzie Smith or George Brett ever think they were watching a HOFer in Kaat? (Sorry, Brett wasn't on this year's committee; Wikipedia's page was kind of confusing. Anyway, he's tagged, and was on previous veterans committees. Besides, that was a sidebar observation that is still valid of Ozzie, who played both with and against Kaat, and doesn't change the larger argument of "you saw X play, did you really think he was a HOFer"?)

Bud Fowler? With basically no stats to consider, he's anecdote and legend. Wouldn't have voted him in. Is he being voted in for being "considered" the first black professional baseball player? That's about as sketchy as his lack of stats. And, yes, I'm being curmudgeonly. Besides, I've always heard Moses Fleetwood Walker was the answer to this question. Fowler only counts if we're talking about minor leagues. Comes off as tokenism, especially if Walker is NOT in. (I had very honestly never heard of Fowler before a week ago.)

Let's tackle these individually, setting aside O'Neil, who we all know should have been in, and Fowler, who I just dealt with.

Miñoso? (Per the third commenter's note, B-Ref's linker runs his name WITHOUT the tilde. But, I have changed that. It still doesn't change my argument or its strength.) 50 WAR. (For various reasons, rightly or wrongly, I don't generally count Negro Leagues numbers on a player considered primarily for his MLB time. A Red Satan piece on Oscar Charleson spells it out for me. B-Ref has scanty enough info on Negro League parks that it cannot park-neutralize OPS+, per the story — and on the flip side, presumably can't park-neutralize ERA+, or calculate FIP, let alone to do a FIP+ like Fangraphs. Because of not having the same minor league structure and individual teams not having minor league systems, B-Ref also can't calculate WAR for Negro Leagues players. For him particularly, he didn't play full time in the Negro Leagues before being signed by the Indians in 1949 at age 23 and put an asterisk on that.)

He was a below-average fielder (he was). He got thrown out on the bases a lot. One 8-WAR, one 6-WAR year. He's not a horrible inductee, but not great.

Back to that asterisk? For anybody talking "but include the Negro Leagues"? Fine. Per B-Ref, he's still under 55 WAR. Given that those were young years, he probably wouldn't have been in MLB's majors most that time were this 20-30 years later and discrimination in playing weren't such a problem, so I still don't see him as much more than 55 WAR. Remember, that when he DID get his initial shot, with the 1949 Indians, he was sent ... to the minors, not back to Negro League ball ... because he wasn't good enough. (The Undefeated, in its fellation of Miñoso, admits that Cleveland was [ahead of the Dodgers!] baseball's most integrated team in 1949. It then raises the "Gold Gloves" argument; well, in two of his three winning seasons, he had a negative dWAR. They didn't exist back then, but that's why cognoscenti look at Fielding Bible awards today.)

Gil Hodges? No 7-WAR seasons. Only one 6-WAR year. Under 45 WAR. Never a top-5 MVP. Not that much as a manager. And, per my response to the first commenter? Alleged sabermetric genyuses like Jay Jaffe are selective on sabermetrics. What good is it appealing to metrics if you're going to ignore or fudge them, Jay? (That's why it's funny as hell to use the cover of his book as illustration for this post.) And, per my crack above? Under 45 WAR and no 7-WAR seasons, yeah, maybe you are a AAA HOFer, but you're NOT a AAAA-replacement level HOFer let alone the real deal.

Would he have been a great manager had he lived? Sabermetrics say no; the 1970 Mets finished 5 games under Pythag; the 1971 Mets were 3 games under. The Senators were over Pythag in 1964-67, but stayed over when jumped to the Mets in 1968.

Kaat? Flat 50 WAR. Look up "compiler" in the MLB Encyclopedia. His picture is there. He even admits it. Falls below 1.10 ERA+, one of my benchmarks besides WAR for a pitcher.Also fails the second, with a WHIP above 1.25. (Black Jack Morris also failed these.) To be a bit charitable, he did have two 7-WAR seasons.

Oliva. Under 50 WAR. Almost EXACTLY another Harold Baines. I don't care if he won three batting titles. Bill Madlock won four and he's not in the HOF either, and he shouldn't be in the HOF either. (Madlock might be an even better comp than Baines.)

I write this as MLBTR's piece on the election has idiots galore in the comments. Beyond the idiots touting candidacies of the undeserving, there's the "greenies were as bad as roids' idiots. They're not and I tackled that six years ago. That said, per the old "Canseco milkshake" and related, there is probably at least one roider already in the Hall. Click the link for my guess on who.

Oh, I've battled the "Big Hall" issue for more than a decade. See here, for example, when Red Satan writers and others complained about a "backlog." Red Satan has tainted a lot of minds, and amplified others, obviously. Jaffe, mentioned above about being sabermetrically selective, was another whiner about an alleged "backlog."

==

Meanwhile, the biggest travesty continues in that Danny Murtaugh was STILL not voted in as a manager. Two WS champs, two other NL East champs, all while battling multiple rounds of the disease that would kill him. 

Bad Bill Dahlen also robbed. Over 70 WAR. Actually deserving.

==

Notes on commeters: "Unknown" had one reasonable comment on Pinson. Other than that, he (I presume) is hitting an increased level of smugness and worse, as well as willfully reading past my comments that I don't want anybody in the Hall, and also not commenting back on the worthiness of those I mentioned, such as Dahlen and Murtaugh on this vote, or Munson and Whitaker elsewhere.

Comment moderation exists for a reason.

No, WAR is not perfect, but, in an actually good piece at Red Satan, I quote:

The goal of WAR is to give the most complete sense of a player's value to his team, and it's perhaps the best piece of data to compare the greatness of one player to the next.
There you go. Couldn't have said it better myself. Now, get off my lawn.

Greenwald, Leighton Woodhouse omit some White Coat details


 That's true, the above picture, about stupidity and COVID contrarian grifting just as much as the virus itself. Let's dig in.

The headline? That's, of course, the White Coat Waste Project, full name. (Named as such, and NOT the "White Coat Animal Safety Project" or similar.) Put an asterisk in that.

This is an expansion of a Twitter thread from last week, after Glennwald hosted Woodhouse at his own Substack.

First Tweet is straight up. (And, the Two Stooges were tagged.)

And, I remember MSM coverage. It was reported straight-up, without the humongous outrage that WCWP founder Anthony Bellotti or the likes of COVID contrarian or worse Woodhouse (put an asterisk in that) or public health denialist and libertarian (you ARE) Glennwald (put an asterisk in that) would like. Some of the MSM questioned WCWP's bona fides. I half-bit, noting that its VP of marketing and policy, Justin Goodman, was former PETA. (Put an asterisk in that, too. We'll get to them all.) 

Next? This.

Frum names people like Cancun Ted Cruz as the weaponizers of this. But, before that, it seems like the likes of Woodhouse were doing their own. Maybe even WCWP, including the former PETA VP, . Bellotti's a definite conservative, but some PETA folks are, too. And, even if not? COVID's heavily illustrated horseshoe theory is true, contra the likes of Noah Berlatsky.

Weaponization, did I say? This:

That's what that is. This was an attack on Fauci, not NIAID. And, there's one obvious reason why. So, it wasn't even Woodhouse who led the weaponization, and this is before Bellotti and White Coat Toxic Waste Dump got the funding on one project wrong, as well as not caring to check if Fauci personally signed off on ones approved by NIAID.

Now, back to the Batman and Robin of current headline grifters:

Technically, the two options aren't mutually exclusive. Woodhouse's "just asking questions" on his Substack and Glennwald opening challenging public health issues re COVID could well be idiocy, not a grifting appeal to the crowd.

Onward. Next Tweet ties with the previous:

Eventually, White Coat, which is now looking like as much a PR machine as Syria's White Helmets, did reference it being an animal rights group, per the link in that Tweet. But, it never did when founded. 

Besides, there's the old "waste, fraud and abuse" strawmanning. Anybody who's read about the Sacklers and Purdue Pharma over opioids, or Jamie Dimon and JPMorgan about just about anything a bankster can do wrong, know that "waste, fraud and abuse" abound in private sector businesses.

And, to wrap up? Here you go:

Glennwald's blocked me on Twitter, but before he did, I got receipts from there. Before that, I got receipts from him unfairly blaming Brazilian lockdowns, not the fact that he and porn co-producer David Miranda are Brazilian 0.1 percenters, for the robbery of their Brazilian McMansion. I'm not even going to link to his or Woodhouse's Substacks, not even with a "no follow." But, I did get receipts on him months ago, when he first showed that he was both a COVID contrarian and a tribalist. (If I had remembered that earlier, I probably never would have even half-bit on White Coat Toxic Waste Dump, I mean White Coat Waste Project.

That said, as with the Fauci emails, it takes two sides to fuel flames on tribalism, and Fauci himself, along with much of BlueAnon, is willing to play Br'er Rabbit to the Tar Baby, or vice versa.

Greenwald? It's past tribalism with him; it's cultism by fanbois, which include Greens dumb enough to think he's a leftist.

At the same time, there's still the issue of the puppies. Several thoughts:

1. Is there any of this that can be at least partially replaced by computer simulation?

2. On what can't, why are we using purebred pups instead of getting abandoned dogs from shelters, especially ones that aren't "no-kill," and thus would have fewer qualms about surrendering animals to research.

3. At the same time, a research organization backing continued use of animals notes that when he was still at PETA, Justin Goodman made many inaccurate claims about animal welfare in research. The animal welfare complaints that didn't exist are similar to NIAID noting that (as far as it could tell) welfare guidelines were followed. Also, don't forget, if you didn't know, that PETA kills animals.

4. Is this battle, Fauci and COVID aside, have we descended to another tribalism? Probably.

December 03, 2021

Zion Williamson still not back ... time to talk? (Updated Dec. 10)

The Pelicans' would-be phenom, Zion Williamson, has new pain in his surgically repaired (we think) foot ... and his return to duty is delayed again. (And? He's been delayed again Dec. 10. And, he's had an injection in his foot Dec. 16; won't be back for four more weeks.)

Many of people have talked about the load he carries at his height of 6-6 and around 285 pounds. Marcus Spears at ESPN mentioned him possibly having a meniscus problem.

But, the feet are the biggie.

Is it time to mention names like Bill Walton? Sam Bowie for younger fans? Greg Oden for younger yet? (I forgot about a near-contemporary of Oden's, Michael Olowokandi, aka the Kandi Man.)

That said, if he's got knee problems, they're transitioning to his feet. And, the knees will continue to challenge him defensively.

Oh, it's not "fat shaming" to ask about his weight. Charles Barkley, at the same height, and known as the "Round Mount of Rebound," carried 30 or so fewer pounds.

The Dawn of Everything? Rather, a mendacious scrapbook pastiche

If late friend Leo Lincourt, a lover of David Graeber, were still alive, he'd surely disagree with me, both in my take on this book and on his previous "Debt," based on the second of not one but TWO fluffy New Yorker reviews, even though I have on record from my RIP for Graeber that Leo at least admitted he was "uneven."

But, from what I first read on the Atlantic's review, and now at the Guardian excerpt?

I think it's oversold. WAY oversold now that The Nation has crushed it.

(Note: This is an updated and expanded version of the review posted on my philosophy blog, designed to not only look at the newer information about the book, but to focus more on the political angles behind it. That review was more about facts, or lack of them, on history and social sciences and interpretation.)

That starts and ends with the title and subtitle: "The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity."

It's overarching, and oversold. And, especially via that review at The Nation and Brad DeLong? It's arguably mendacious, not just oversold. (That said, per the title, overselling something willfully is part of being mendacious, is it not?)

(Note: This is a reworking of the original review on my philosophy blog. That's in part because the second fluffy New Yorker review reminds me of Graeber's connections with Occupy and the Black Bloc, which I have long despised, and that puts us into modern politics.

Note 2: I have now given it a MUCH more thorough deconstruction at Goodreads, with a 2-star review.)

I've read multiple books that have already touched on how the old archaeological and anthropological paradigm of a straight,  permanent, line from hunter-gathering  to farming is wrong. Against the Grain covered this four years ago. Five years ago, John Wathey offered up new ideas on the development of early religion and spirituality, which this pair don't appear to cover at all.

Or, via Academia.edu, while not discussing the early "civilizations" of Southwest Asia, here's a paper FROM 1998 about the Fremont culture of today's Utah, discussing a mix of part-time foragers/part-time farmers, full-time foragers, full-time farmers, farmers who flipped to foraging and foragers who became farmers. (Unlike in the Old World, pastoral nomadism wasn't an option in most the New World before Columbian contact, due to lack of domesticated livestock, of course.)

OR? I'll certainly venture that their "everything" doesn't include a new date of 50,000 years, yes FIFTY THOUSAND years before present for the oldest figural, representational human-created art.

So, the pair aren't saying anything new, they're building on others, and right there, it's not a new history, and it's not complete, so not "everything."

It also smacks to me of trying to build on the reputation of Graeber, who died in the last year. Now, he could have been a great capitalist within his anarchism; anarcho-capitalism is a thing, complete with its own Wiki page. But, from what I know of Graeber on my own and via Leo? Uh, no. He would have shuddered to be in the same breath (I think) as Murray Rothbard. (Per the Guardian extract, that's why it's funny for the duo to talk about capitalists talking about social connections at Christmas WITH the implication that they're doing that INSTEAD OF capitalism rather than as a marketing adjunct.)

Now, to some specifics, via a trio of (unanswered, Twitter, natch, low signal to noise ratio) Tweets to the author of the Atlantic review.

First, I noted the pair were by no means alone, per the above.

Second, I noted that the HIGHLY sympathetic reviewer, William Deresciewicz, undercut himself in links in his piece, one in particular, in the claim that "towns" existed long before a permanent shift to agriculture (note that I also tagged Wengrow, also unresponsive):

Finally, I said that, at least per what the review says and more importantly, doesn't say, it's NOT about "everything."

OK,

Now, off to the Guardian excerpt, since I saw that later.

First, the pair are right that just about all of us, including our African Homo sapiens ancestors before leaving Africa, have DNA and mitochondrial DNA from other species within us. Nonetheless, that's yet more dilute than the bits of Neanderthal and / or Denisovan DNA that the typical non-African has. Ergo, the concept of "DNA Adam" and "mitochondrial DNA Eve" is still a good working theory and Graber-Wengrow come close to strawmanning. (The pair actually had a chance of tackling residual racial bias in human population genetics, that said, but at least here, appear to take a pass.)

Second, since cultural evolution is not evolution, unless the pair are slaves to evolutionary psychology, this is largely irrelevant to cultural evolution, contra their claims. So, without reading the full book? Lost a star. And, ev psych has a lot of political tie-ins and overtones as well. Seems to me like they're undercutting some of their other politics to even flirt with it. See Steve Gould and Richard Lewontin.

Third, they do next admit previous recent study of places like Göbekli Tepe, so a kudo of sorts back. That said, I see it as like Pueblo Bonito and the whole Chaco Canyon structures. We still don't know for sure what THAT was — permanent settlement, religious site with sparse permanent inhabitation, some mix of that, or something else. They're just claiming it was X not Y without support.

Fourth, it may be true that inequalities of various sorts were actually worse before a permanent transition to agriculture and a permanent transition to settled cities. Or it may not be. Right now, there's just not enough evidence to say that. We do have enough evidence to say we should get rid of old paradigms, but not enough to create new ones. Contra cheap versions of hot takes on Thomas Kuhn, paradigm shifts as in not just abandoning an old one but immediately replacing it with a new one, just aren't that common.

OK, so they got that much wrong about the past. And more.

Via Molly Fischer, the second fluffy New Yorker review (I'll get to her in a minute), leading me to a Brad DeLong Tweet, I see The Nation has some skepticism about the book, too. Daniel Immerwahr nails it, which is why DeLong Tweeted the link:

(H)e was better known for being interesting than right, and he would gleefully make pronouncements that either couldn’t be confirmed (the Iraq War was retribution for Saddam Hussein’s insistence that Iraqi oil exports be paid for in euros) or were never meant to be (“White-collar workers don’t actually do anything”).

Yep. Now, that's today's politics, but Immerwahr also tackles the past that they tackle.

Just before that, Immerwahr noted a tendentious reading of Mayan ruins by the pair, claiming that the site in question does NOT show "lords" or similar.

The latter third of the review raises a big-ticket item. Accepting that late Neolithic humans did indeed "experiment" with sedentary farming, state structures, etc., for 2-3 millennia or more, at some point, they "locked in" and we became "stuck." This is definitely true in most of Eurasia plus North Africa, and also true, albeit at a lower level of hierarchy and without firm territories, in the Americas and much of sub-Saharan Africa pre-Columbian contact. And, Immerwahr says they never answer why this happened, at least not in satisfactory fashion. 

Since they can't construct an overarching narrative for that? He says that makes the book a "scrapbook" as much as anything.

At the New Yorker, Gideon Lewis-Krous also appears to give it a fluffy review, the first of the two I noted. His take is addressed between me and Immelwahr, above. He also petard-hoists, re what Immelwahr says about interpreting Mayan ruins at Tikal. They basically claim that about everybody else has gotten it wrong but voila, here we are! And we know you're all right rather than all wet why?

Lewis-Krous doesn't address the Immelwahr bottom line critique, either. At some point, whether triumphalist or defeatist, to use his words, much of the world DID "lock in" on sedentary agriculture. Per my notes above about the Americas and sub-Saharan Africa, while hunter-gatherers will have very limited rulerships and hierarchies, this is not the same as "none." And, pastoral nomadists have plenty of both. Genghis Khan, anybody?

In turn, that seems to be, from all the reviews, something the pair just ignores. After all, after livestock were domesticated in the Old World, and especially after somebody realized you could ride a horse instead of eating it, boom! Pastoral nomadism became a third alternative to both hunter-gatherer and sedentary agriculture lifestyles. BUT! As I see it, it requires a conscious commitment and you can't wobble in and back out of it.

On to a second New Yorker fellation of Graeber and the book by Molly Fischer. Fischer does remind me of Graeber not only being the "intellectual voice" behind Occupy, but a supporter of Black Bloc types, including their property destruction, which this leftist of some sort has long rejected. It also reminds me of the lies told about Occupy in general and Occupy New York in particular being "leaderless," which it was not. Fischer starts with New York City's Direct Action Network, a predecessor of Occupy NY that got a new round of prominence after the Black Bloc destructiveness at the Seattle WTO event in 1998. 

I should note that this is why, other than what I've called the pretentiousness of the name, I don't identify with the so-called "antifa": their Black Bloc roots, including the anarchism. A lot of this gets coupled with myths about the police, whether from anarchists, New Left not including them, or libertarians. I've exploded many of them.

With that, per Fischer's piece, I wonder if Graeber, with the Malagasy and others of his anthropology work, while being right on them being anarchist in not having formal governments, nonetheless had leadership structures that he either flat missed, or ignored by de-emphasis, or else willfully turned a blind eye to. I say that because of his claim that Occupy "worked," a claim rejected by many people who, like him, were involved with it.

Re what I said above about their work, the Graeber-Wengrow for the book, not being new? Fischer reports that professional colleagues said at first, on their first journal submission, that it was insufficiently new. They should have stuck with that.

As for "Debt"? First, Brad DeLong has receipts on how error-ridden it is. And, how smug and defiant Graeber is about the errors. (Note Lewis-Krous review.)

Second, per this blog post, I long ago tackled the bullshit claim that Occupy Wall Street was leaderless. And, for Graeber, a PhD anthropologist, to claim that it was? That's mendaciousness. Given that he was essentially a cofounder of OWS, and he and Marissa Holmes were acknowledged as "primus inter partes," and all the other leadership sociological structures mentioned at at the second link, he knew it was bullshit. And, per those links, by lying about OWS leaderlessness, Graeber was ultimately an accomplice to bandit predatory capitalism. He was also arguably an accomplice to the classism and racism that a good anarchist should have despised, as self-done demographic surveys indicate that Occupy Wall Street had a fair chunk of both, and with that, probably was largely nowhere near as idealistic as Graeber tried to make it out to be.

Third, per what Fischer seems to say about it, Graeber seems to have the same belief about how antiquity treated debt as does Michael Hudson. I've dealt with Hudson before; in brief, he takes the aspirational stances of ancient texts on debt jubilees as realities. Any good biblical critic knows better about Israel. Second, to flat-foot Graeber, this was nation-states doing this. Private lenders can't be forced to tear up debts on their own without the power of a nation-state. I can, as a private person, per the Lukan version of the Lord's Prayer, forgive a debt. But, short of a nation-state, who will force me? Likewise, per Jesus' parable of the two debtors, I can't force anybody to pay it forward. Pre-state society may not have been as brutish as Hobbes posits. But, the evolutionary biology problem of free riders hits Homo sapiens as much if not more, than any other eusocial species.

I tackled this most recently in that RIP up top; here it is again.

As for modern monetary theory, dinging both him and Hudson again? I called it a Maoist cult.

And, I'm glad I did this longer update as, per the RIP link, it reminds me that I indeed won't miss Graeber that much. Nor any cult around him.

Update, Dec. 22: Here's another way of seeing what's wrong with the book, to summarize the first part of this post: It's "Big History," with all its problems, including its myth-creation.

==

Update, July 19, 2022: Turns out not all the mendacity is Graeber's. Per a fawning review of the book mixed with a fawning interview of Wengrow, Wired's Virginia Heffernan (who, per past Twitter call-outs of her, has reached her Peter Principle) says that Wengrow invented the book title.

As the story goes on, it's clear that Heffernan ignores not only criticisms of what the pair got wrong, but also critiques like mine that a fair chunk of what the pair did get right is nowhere near new and in fact, re the Agricultural Non-Revolution, has been academically discussed for 20 years. It's also a flat lie that this critic balks at its ambition more than its research, exactly for the reasons of intellectual theft I just mentioned.

I will add a compendium of two other criticisms that she linked.

The first is devastating, noting that the pair appear to reject evolutionary theory. That's a move by many leftists who conflate Darwinism and social Darwinism, or use the idea that others conflate them to reject both. The same reviewer also notes that their world civilizational survey basically just ignores sub-Saharan Africa!

The second starts out by petard-hoisting the pair, always good in my book. It goes on to secondly note their angle remains anarchism first, socialism or even Marxism a distant second. And, that this too colors their background thoughts. Note what I said above about their take on "out of Africa" and human evolution. This ties in with that review.

December 02, 2021

Texas Progressives head back to the grind

A slow week with Thanksgiving, but not totally slow, so let's dive in.

The race to succeed Eddie Bernice Johnson is heating up. (The person I put money on, Carl Sherman, hasn't yet filed, but, there's time.)

ERCOT can't guarantee we won't have another winter power outage.

Jonathan Tilove talks to Julian Castro about his post-2022 plans, his thoughts on Dems in South Texas, and more.

Speaking of South Texas, at the Observer, Gus Bova looks at Jessica Cisneros' second run at CD 28.

Comptroller Glenn Hegar, the one halfway sane Republican holding statewide office, is proposing new rules for Chapter 313 projects, even as Chapter 313 itself ends, that critics say will lessen transparency and accountability. (For the unfamiliar, Chapter 313 allowed taxing entities like school districts and hospital districts to grant the functional equivalent of abatements to folks like wind farms.) Basically, what Hegar wants to 86 is data on things like job production agreements that were part of many Chapter 313 projects. 

Off the Kuff dives into the new Congressional map to see what opportunities may await.

SocraticGadfly talked about Gohmert Pyle's announcement and ramifications, both for AG and for CD1. 

Emily Eby says a fond goodbye to the Texas Civil Rights Project. 

Mean Green Cougar Red looks forward to USFL 2.0.  

Andrea Grimes understands what the "University of Austin" is all about.

National and global

Meet Fulton County, Georgia's first Black woman DA, Fani Willis. Willis, like other DAs Black, White or other ethnicity, male or female, who were elected on "progressive DA" campaigns, is facing scrutiny and backlash. With her, unlike a Chesea Boudin, as with some others, it's that she's still too tough on crime, too friendly to cops. She says she's cleared out a bunch of old prosecutors from her office, but the critics aren't satisfied. Beyond Black vs White and other issues, her seeking the death penalty in the Asian spa shootings case is also a flash point.

Ray Billingsley, creator of "Curtis," is the first Black cartoonist to win that profession's top honor, the Reuben Award.

Il Papa, the Pope, Francis the Talking Pope, offers his definition of journalism while making an award.