What? Gnu Atheists NOT raptured to Mecca?

Well, the day is over and I haven't seen any Gnu Atheists raptured to Mecca to draw friendly, cuddly pictures of Muhammad for pilgrims at the hajj. Soooooo disappointed.

But, since both the rapture-Not! and Draw Muhammad Day are about done, you can still Draw a Gnu Atheist.

As I said on the Draw Muhammad post, "cui bono"? To what benefit is this day?

Does it, in and of itself, actually bolster free speech that much? Probably not much more than Justice Holmes' famous dictum about yelling fire in a crowded theater. What would probably help more is writing the U.S. and UN embassies of relatively moderate Islamic-majority countries, encouraging them to be more supportive of free speech, countries such as, say Jordan or Turkey.

Does it benefit more liberal-minded Muslims? Of course not. Especially in countries of some openness in the Muslim world, by painting a picture of yet more Americans tarring all Muslims with the same brush, it backfires, and potentially hurts them. That said, the majority of Gnu ringleaders, or "cadre formers," if you're P.Z. Myers (his post on the Mooney-Lindsey interview), prefer to lump the masses of believers of any religion with the most regressive elements within them.

Does it actually do anything vis-a-vis fundamentalist Muslim leaders? Of course not. It won't get them to suddenly "repent" of violence, narrow-mindedness, misogyny or other actual or alleged defects.

Does it benefit atheism or secular humanism in general? Absolutely not, and especially not in those countries I just mentioned.

Draw Muhammad Day is like using a shotgun instead of a rifle. Of course, for PZ, Jerry Coyne, et al, seem to like confrontation for confrontation's sake. Like ... Lenin! Another "cadre former" was he, after all.

Quotable quotes updated – religion, prophecy, atheism

“There is no god but Allah and Muhammad is his prophet” — Quran
“There is no god, and I am his prophet” — SocraticGadfly

I don’t claim to be as strident an atheist as Chris Hitchens.

Nor is my riposte meant to be anti-Muslim.

But, in the United States, more people who are secularists need to stand up for their unbeliefs.

It’s hypocritical when Kevin Drum claims to be a “godless blogger” in a blog post, but has never, ever, to the best of my knowledge, actually written a post about his personal atheist take on life.

Got a famous quote you’d like to see updated? Drop me a line at socraticgadflyAThotmailDOTcom.