SocraticGadfly: Finally someone gets religious opt-outs of medical treatment right

April 07, 2008

Finally someone gets religious opt-outs of medical treatment right

Renowned medical ethicist Arthur Caplan says prosecute the parents of children that die from not being taken to a doctor, not being vaccinated, etc.

Even if the parents do so on religious grounds, prosecute them, he says.
Parents do not have the right to watch a child wither away while they pray. Parents do not have the right to watch a child convulse in pain while they pray. Parents should understand that if a child is in agony, if a child is slowly dying before their eyes, that they have an absolute duty, the same as any other parent — religious or not — to call the police, an ambulance or emergency services.

One state has gotten that message. Oregon is trying Carl and Raylene Worthington for manslaughter after they let their 15-month-old daughter die from bronchial pneumonia and a blood infection, praying over her while refusing to take her to a doctor, get her medicine, etc.

Caplan says that even if the Worthingtons never spend a day in jail, it sends the right message.

Frankly, I think they need to spend jail time. Not the rest of their lives, but a year and a day.

And, unless they will sign a consent agreement with the state to get proper medical attention for any future children they may conceive, I think both Worthingtons ought to be sterilized.

No comments: