SocraticGadfly: Maybe it's time to start being kinder to ourselves

June 05, 2011

Maybe it's time to start being kinder to ourselves

Probably originating in 12-Step groups, I have heard plenty of admonitions, chidings and warnings in various locales in life about "pity pots" and "pity parties."

But, some new psychological research says that maybe we need to stop worrying so much about "pity parties" and instead have more concern about how kind we are to ourselves.

A LOT more concern, including learning it as a top-level life skill.

This is NOT the "give every kid an A to boost self esteem," the study makes clear. In fact, it notes that that technique often backfires, and can lead to neuroticism, emotional fragility and narcissism.

"It is not this nimby, bimby stuff," said Paul Gilbert, a researcher at Kingsway Hospital in the United Kingdom. "Compassion is sensitivity to the suffering of self and others and a commitment to do something about it."

Kristin Neff, an associate professor of psychology and the mother of an autistic child, writes about cultivating self-compassion from her own parenting experience as well as her professional background, in the just-published book, "Self-Compassion."

She lists three aspects to it: mindfulness, common humanity and kindness.

Mindfulness, whether done as a full meditative practice or not, is as Neff describes it, accepting emotions without either suppressing/blocking them OR fixating on/attaching to them.

Common humanity is, to riff on another old phrase from "the other folks," recognizing that our hurts and pains aren't "terminally unique" either.

And, kindness is kindness to ourselves as well as others.

The LiveScience authors go on to note that self-esteem of the type I stereotypically mentioned above still have a competitive and comparative element to it. Self-kindness does not.

And, speaking of competitiveness, other researchers, the story notes, believe that as the pace of modern Western life accelerates, self-punishment will likely increase.

But, won't being kind to ourselves a lot lead to a temptation to "let ourselves off the hook"? No, but that's been anticipated too:

(A)ccording to Neff, the most common fear about becoming self-compassionate is that it will lower performance standards and encourage laziness. But researchers have found that self-compassionate people are actually less likely to sit on the couch all day eating bonbons.
So, lighten up. Especially on yourself. And let's encourage each other on this.

2 comments:

CJS said...

I am glad to see your opposition to the 12-step cult – this should be a leading issue for freethinkers, as the 12-step cult constitutes by far the greatest encroachment of religion on society. In no other venue can people be forced into religion under cover of law or medicine, let alone both. Where is the outrage?

I am curious as to the extent of your experience or deprogramming. “Pity pot” and “terminally unique” are extraordinarily vicious and abusive concepts which would not be tolerated anywhere else. Imaging any other circumstance where the response to any speck of information about yourself would be “Oh, so you’re terminally unique”.

Gadfly said...

CJ, I was involved with AA on a fairly high activity level for 2-plus years, including being local group leader, whatever the hell the AA title is.

I originally posted a longer version of this on the blog of Lifering Secular Recovery, online at lifering.org.

So I am still involved with these support issues, but from a much different perspective.

Also, the "big book" on "those who fail," etc.? Those people are, in indirect language, being called sociopaths.

Anyway, if you're involved with sobriety issues, too, visit Lifering's website ... and pass it on!